ICP
  • About
    • ICP for Programs, Financiers, and Green Banks >
      • GHG Accounting
      • Adaptive Reuse
      • Certification Timing
      • Post-Cert Changes
    • How Does ICP Work? >
      • Project Framework
      • Roadmap to IREE Certification
    • GGRF EPA Reporter
    • Tech Forum >
      • Technical Forum Blog
      • Discussion Notes
      • Call Recordings
      • Reference Documents
      • Glossary
      • Acronyms
      • Protocol Archives
    • ICP in Canada
    • Contact Us
  • Training
  • IREE Certification
    • Guide to IREE Certification
    • Commercial Protocols >
      • Large Commercial
      • Standard Commercial
      • Targeted Commercial
      • Basic / Performance
    • Multifamily Protocols >
      • Large Multifamily
      • Standard Multifamily
      • Targeted Multifamily
      • Basic / Performance
    • Project Development Specification
    • Project Registration >
      • Performance Update
    • Tools and Templates >
      • Cx, O&M, M&V Templates
      • QA Checklists
      • Building Button
    • Case Studies
  • Providers
    • Project Developer Network >
      • Join the ICP PD Network
    • Quality Assurance Assessors >
      • Join ICP's Quality Assurance Asserssors
  • Blog
    • Blog
    • ICP In the News

Quality Assurance Technical Forum Notes

4/30/2014

Comments

 
Resources / Tools / Thoughts
Data - historical energy usage
  • completeness of data collection and validity of data
  • utility data analysis - stability and normalization
  • retrofit isolation baseline development
  • Universal Translator v3 - The UT3 is software designed for the management and analysis of data from loggers and trend data from building management systems. The software features import routines, time and interval correction, calibration error correction, data filters, charting tools, and export capabilities. It also features analysis modules to analyze economizers, lighting loads, plug loads, psychometrics, setpoints, statistics, control loop diagnostics, fans, AHUs, terminal units, fan coils, and an M&V analysis module (regression modeling).
  • ASTM E2797-11 Building Energy Performance Assessment (BEPA) Standard
  • Develop baseline regression model using the ASTM E2797-11 Building Energy Performance Assessment Standard methodology or the ASHRAE Inverse Modeling Toolkit and following ASHRAE Guideline 14-2002
  • ASHRAE Standard 105 - expressing and comparing building energy performance data; benchmarking. ASHRAE Standard 100 - existing buildings, benchmarking, under development; uses CBECS; guidelines for building not in the CBECS database, weather and occupancy adjustment methods - under final public review (out within a year)
Data - and building system operation / building asset data
  • building data collection methods and processes
  • asset data collection
  • operational and performance data collection
  • ANSI/BOMA Z65.3-2009
  • ASHRAE Procedures for Commercial Building Energy Audits (Second Edition 2011)
  • Commercial Buildings Energy Consumption Survey (CBECS) 2003 - new coming out this year
  • SimuWatt - tablet based energy auditing and data collection tool - proprietary
  • Inverse Modeling Toolkit
  • BEDES - Building Energy Data Exchange Specification (LBNL) - energy audit sub group, focused on standardizing audits; should be ready in the next couple of months
  • DOE Asset Rating System - EnergyPlus engine; generates a scoring for benchmarking / screening tool, but more detail than just billing data (beta phase)
Investment criteria
  • SPB, SIR, IRR, NPV
  • LCCA - NIST Life Cycle Costing Handbook 135
  • International Energy Efficiency Financing Protocol, 2009 (EVO) - the global “blue print” for educating and training LFI personnel around the world on the special intricacies, benefits and risks associated with financing ESPs. It is intended to be a growing set of best practices, resource materials, case studies, standardized tools and guidelines to support LFIs and other energy efficiency stakeholders in their economic and financial evaluation of ESPs.
  • Jeff Hirsch - DOE2.com; NIST DLCC financing approach
  • RMI - LCAID - Excel based tool for financial analysis
  • FEMP - financial summary tools for ESCo projects; finance schedules in the contract
  • RETScreen - financial calcs built in
Cost estimates
  • Implementation cost reasonableness
  • RS Means and previous estimates
  • GSA - developed unit pricing for green features; study performed cost-benefit analysis (pricing framework)
Energy modeling
  • quality assurance and calibration
  • ECM modeling
  • BEM Library (RMI); BEM Stack Exchange Platform (Big Ladder Software); BEMBook Wiki  (IBPSA-USA); COMNET (IMT/NBI); RMI working on risked-based building energy modeling resources (vetted go to for modeling procedures); ASHRAE energy modeling standard 209 also in the works (two to three years
  • NYSERDA Multifamily Performance Program Existing Buildings Component Simulation Guidelines
  • FEMP 2.2 Guidelines
  • BEM Library Office Benchmarks
  • Energy Modeling Input Translator (EMIT) - RMI’s website
  • Procedures for Commercial Energy Modeling - checklist at ASHRAE.org/pcbea; also a template for ECM summary table; audit forms
Spreadsheet calculations
  • quality assurance regarding methods and assumptions
  • reasonability review methods
  • Uniform Methods Project; FEMP Guidelines
  • BPA - has handful of equipment specific calculators
  • CA Cx Collaborative website - Excel add-in; ficus on RCx, weather only for CA; but has this Excel add-in to do profile analysis on building data; diagnostics; handles monthly data
  • ECAM - regression analysis (baselining and savings)
Operational performance verification
  • resources
  • report templates
  • system manuals - concise
  • IPMVP discusses OPV
  • Efficiency Valuation Organization (EVO) - templates and resources
  • PNNL - Retuning - guidelines (sort of like ongoing Cx; uses ECAM tool)
Operations, maintenance and monitoring
  • FDD tools / resources
  • RCx tools / resources
  • Operator’s manual templates
  • Training - BPI’s Technical Standards for the MF Energy Efficient Building Operator
  • RS Means - preventative maintenance system
  • ASHRAE Standard 180 - recommended maintenance by different types of equipment
  • Training - Building Operator’s Certification Program (Pacific Northwest) - NW Energy Efficiency Council
M&V
  • Automated tools
  • Resources
  • Templates (M&V plans and reports)
  • IPMVP; ASHRAE Guideline 14 Whole Building Performance Path; ASTM E2797-11 Building Energy Performance Assessment (BEPA) Standard data collection methodology
  • IPMVP Concise; M&V templates
  • ASHRAE Guideline 14 - specific examples for Option A and B
  • UT3
Uncertainty and risk
  • methods for determining / quantifying uncertainty
  • methods for determining risk
  • Monte Carlo
  • Open Studio - NREL; uncertainty analysis / parametric analysis - can do a huge number of runs (beta version)  - modeling
  • ECAM - savings determination uncertainty - utility meters (error)
Miscellaneous
  • energy calcs; no matter what method they use, make sure baseline is based on real data; end-use comparison is performed; energy balance as a fundamental piece
  • ASHRAE energy cost budget - forces them to perform QA; for energy modeling
  • How do you document that the energy balance has been performed? ASHRAE (90.1) baseline for proposed buildings; can be applied to existing buildings too
Comments

Quality Assurance Protocol Technical Forum Agenda

4/23/2014

Comments

 
Tuesday, April 29, 2014
1 pm EST (60 min)
Conference Number: (415) 854-0868

Compile and discuss available resources, tools, and best practices regarding quality assurance methods.

QA Checklist Elements:
  • Data - historical energy usage
    • completeness of data collection and validity of data
    • utility data analysis - stability and normalization
    • retrofit isolation baseline development
  • Data - and building system operation / building asset data
    • building data collection methods and processes
    • asset data collection
    • operational and performance data collection
  • Data - load profile
    • data collection and analysis
  • Investment criteria
    • SPB, SIR, IRR, NPV
  • Cost estimates
    • Implementation cost reasonableness
  • Energy modeling
    • quality assurance and calibration
    • ECM modeling
  • Spreadsheet calculations
    • quality assurance regarding methods and assumptions
    • reasonability review methods
  • Operational performance verification
    • resources
    • report templates
    • system manuals - concise
  • Operations, maintenance and monitoring
    • FDD tools / resources
    • RCx tools / resources
    • Operator’s manual templates
    • Training
  • M&V
    • Automated tools
    • Resources
    • Templates (M&V plans and reports)
  • Uncertainty and risk
    • methods for determining / quantifying uncertainty
    • methods for determining risk
  • Roles of third-party evaluators
    • currently suggest third party performance of Cx
    • currently suggest third part performance of M&V; at least require third party review of M&V
  • Other QA topics that should be addressed?
Comments

Announcing the Quality Assurance Technical Forum!

4/15/2014

Comments

 
The Investor Confidence Project (ICP) is pleased to announce our next Technical Forum call, which will focus on the development of the Quality Assurance (QA) Specification.  This significant undertaking will address areas of an energy efficiency project that require greater levels of scrutiny and QA, as well as methods, roles and responsibilities associated with the QA process.  The QA Specification will address QA processes and resources applied to each element-procedure-documentation item in the three protocols (Large, Standard, and Targeted Commercial) in a standardized and repeatable process. The ultimate intent is to provide a framework for best practices, and links to QA resources, to assess and minimize risk and uncertainty associated with energy efficiency projects and the cost and complexity for investors to gain confidence in projected savings and therefore cash flows that result from investment in energy efficiency.

The QA Specification will utilize existing guidelines, processes and methods already established in most cases.  If resources for a particular item are not available, a QA method specific to this item will be developed.

This first Technical Forum call is scheduled for Tuesday, April 29th at 1 pm EST.  This call will provide a forum to discuss various industry-accepted methods associated with the protocol tasks, as well as brainstorm available tools and resources for QA.  A complete agenda for this call will be forthcoming next week.

We look forward to a lively discussion with all participants.

Regards,

The ICP Development Team



Comments

    Follow Tech Forum Blog:



    Curated by:

    Tracy Phillips
    ICP Technical Lead


    Archives

    May 2016
    March 2016
    December 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014

    Categories

    All
    Data Access And Management
    Large Commercial
    Quality Assurance
    Standard Commercial

    RSS Feed

Contact the Project